Lancaster County’s Top Five Ice Cream Shops

Lancaster County PA Dairy farms

Where to get ice cream in Lancaster County PASummer is heating up so it’s time to think about cooling down–in the most delicious possible way, of course! Lancaster County is known for many things, including its rolling hills dotted with dairy farms that supply some of the best dairy products in the state.

Isabella’s Ice Cream Parlor: The quaint atmosphere of this old fashioned ice cream shop fits perfectly in small town Lititz, formerly Budget Travel’s “America’s Coolest Small Town.” Serving 24 flavors of Hershey’s ice cream, Isabella’s is a great end to a full summer day. Small and family-run, Isabella’s makes customers feel at home even if they’ve never visited before!

Strasburg Creamery: A favorite destination for many years, this creamery serves homemade ice cream in all the classic flavors plus a few originals that are sure to become old favorites. The old-time high backed booths and wire framed chairs provide a great atmosphere for everything from family outings to romantic afternoons. Plus, you can pop in to the adjacent general store for a little something for the road.

The Milkhouse at Oregon Dairy: It’s not just ice cream when you visit Oregon Dairy. Ideal for families and children, the ice cream is the first draw but the large outdoor porch, full playground, small petting zoo, and nearby deer pen definitely top off the experience.

Lancaster County ice cream shopsFox Meadows Creamery and Country Market: A new addition to Lancaster County’s ice cream shop, Fox Meadows makes their ice cream on site. In addition to such unique flavors as honeyed lavender, orange creamsicle and birthday cake,  Fox Meadows offers a wide wraparound porch with plenty of seating and a great view of some of the county’s finest farmland.

Lapp Valley Farms: The authentic Lancaster County ice cream experience, this shop is off the beaten path. It’s not another world, but it might feel like it when you step into Amish country. Come prepared for some of the creamiest ice cream that you’ve ever tasted along with freshly made waffle cones for a visit that you won’t soon forget.

Choose one shop to visit, or stay a weekend to try out a few. The Lancaster County Bed and Breakfast Inns Association offers premium, homey accommodations for couples, families, and groups of friends. Whether you want to make ice cream a small treat during your visit or take a tour of the local creameries, the innkeepers can provide directions and recommendations to help you plan out your trip.

Skip to content